← Ask the Cheesemonger

Marry Me Meatloaf

Brie Brie Rehak, That Girl Brie cheesemonger
October 3, 2026 · 2 min read

That Girl Brie charcuterie board flat lay with branded wooden lids

Some meatloaf is just dinner. This one is a proposal. Tracy stuffed it with our Portabella & Chive cheese, and here's her original post and recipe.

It's been a minute, huh?

Between business trips, hosting the most amazing special needs picnics, planting grass like I'm auditioning for Better Homes & Gardens, and living in a full-blown construction zone (mental health = fragile), I haven't posted a recipe in a hot sec. Turns out, I'm not a "live laugh love through renovations" kind of girl. Check on me.

But on this frosty May night (rude), I needed comfort food that says "marry me already." So I whipped up Marry Me Meatloaf, stuffed with That Girl Brie's Portabella & Chive Cheese because basic meatloaf just isn't putting a ring on it, ladies.

Mike's been around 28 years and if this is what I served on Day 1, he would've proposed right then and there.

Served with

  • Buttery chunky mashed baby reds
  • Our favorite veggie mix
  • A side of disbelief that it's still winter in May

Ingredients

Mom-approved. Stomach-hugging. Only 7 ingredients (because water and seasoning don't count, rules are rules):

  • 2 lbs ground chuck
  • 1 medium onion, finely diced
  • 1 box Stove Top stuffing
  • ½ cup hot water
  • ½ stick melted butter
  • 2 eggs
  • Portabella & Chive Cheese from That Girl Brie (be generous!)

Seasonings

Worcestershire (aka wash-ya-sister sauce), onion powder, garlic powder, freshly cracked black pepper, salt. Measure with your heart.

Directions

  • Mix your stuffing mix, hot water, and melted butter with a fork.
  • Add in your meat, onion, eggs, and seasonings. Get those hands in there.
  • Press half the mixture into the bottom of a casserole dish.
  • Hollow out a little trench and fill it with as much cheese as your loving heart desires.
  • Top it off with the rest of your meat and seal that love in!
  • Optional (but emotionally required): slather with ketchup and brown sugar glaze (it's what my mama did).
  • Bake at 375°F for 45 to 55 mins until your house smells like someone should propose to you.
  • Serve hot and enjoy the compliments.

Final thoughts

This meatloaf? It doesn't just feed you. It sees you. It gets you.

Ready to make it? Grab Portabella & Chive and more in our artisan cheese collection.

Back to blog
Brie, founder of That Girl Brie

Written by

Brie, founder & cheesemonger

Brie builds every board and hand-picks every Wisconsin cheese at That Girl Brie. She thinks pretty food tastes better and she has never met a cheese pun she didn't like. Read our story

Ready to put this to good use?

Order Wisconsin cheese that ships nationwide, or let us build the board for you.